Now, before you start measuring, you need to ask yourself: how much of that water or oil are you really getting rid of? Because I’ve watched people drain tuna, and let’s be honest—we’re all a little sloppy. If you just dump the can into a colander and give it a half-hearted shake, you’re leaving behind a tablespoon or two of liquid. That messes with your cup count. A properly drained 5-ounce can gives you exactly ½ cup, but a half-drained can? You might end up with closer to ⅔ cup of soggy tuna mush. Moral of the story: squeeze it, press it, or pat it dry with a paper towel if you want precision. Your tuna salad will thank you.
Does the Type of Tuna Matter? (Spoiler: Yes)
You’d think “tuna is tuna,” but no—the texture changes everything. Chunk light tuna tends to flake into smaller pieces, packing more tightly into the can. That 5-ounce chunk light might give you a slightly heftier ½ cup, almost overflowing. Solid white albacore, on the other hand, is chunkier and leaves more air gaps, so you might get a lean ½ cup that looks a bit sad. And then there’s the oil-packed stuff—it’s denser and heavier, so when you drain it, you’ll lose more volume. You could end up with just under ½ cup. Annoying? Yes. Scientifically fascinating? Also yes.
Let’s talk about the packaging illusion for a second. Manufacturers often list “net weight” on the can, which includes the liquid. That 5 ounces? That’s total weight, not tuna alone. After draining, you’re lucky if the tuna itself weighs 4 to 4.5 ounces. So when you’re eyeballing a can and thinking, “That’s gotta be a cup,” you’re being tricked by the marketing gods. It’s like when a bag of chips is half air—same energy, but with more mercury concerns. Seriously, check the label next time; you’ll feel both enlightened and mildly betrayed.
Dietitians Online Blog: World Tuna Day